Food & Feed Research

Quality properties of cookies supplemented with fresh brewer`s spent grain

Volume 44, Issue 1

cookies, brewer's spent grain, colour, sensory properties, microbial profile

TOOLS Creative Commons License

Jovana S. Petrović,*1, Biljana S. Pajin, Sunčica D. Kocić Tanackov, Jelena D. Pejin, Aleksandar Z. Fišteš, Nemanja Đ. Bojanić, Ivana S. Lončarević

University of Novi Sad, Faculty of Technology, 21000 Novi Sad, Bulevar cara Lazara 1, Serbia


Brewer's spent grain (BSG) is a by-product generated during the brewing process. It is a rich source of dietary fibre and proteins, with great potential to increase nutritional value of food products. In this research different quantities of fresh (non-dried and non-milled) brewer's spent grain (15, 25 and 50%) were added to wheat flour on a replacement basis in order to evaluate its effect on fibre and protein content, instrumental parameters of colour, microbial stability and sensory characteristics of cookies. Protein and fibre content of cookies increased following the addition of BSG from 7.55% to 9.69% and 6.8 to 15.55%, respectively. Considering the colour characteristics, addition of BSG decreased L* and b* values, while a* values increased. Enterobacteriaceae, Escherichia coli, Clostridium spp., yeasts and moulds were not detected in cookie samples, while the Enterobacteriaceae were detected (40 cfu/g) in fresh BSG. The addition of 25% of BSG resulted in best sensory characteristics of cookies in terms of surface appearance, hardness, grittiness and flavour. The results have shown that fresh BSG has a potential to increase nutritional value of the cookies without negative influence on cookie sensory characteristics and microbiological stability.


The food and beverage industry produces large quantities of by-products (Stojceska et al., 2008). In recent years, the possibilities for food by-products recovery attracted increasing attention. Many of these waste or by-products contain significant amounts of valuable components and have a potential to be utilized as functional ingredients in order to increase the nutritional value of food products (Rodriguez et al., 2006; Ktenioudaki et al., 2013a, 2013b).

Brewer's spent grain (BSG) is the main by-product generated during the brewing process, available in large quantities throughout the year, and at low cost (Stojceska, 2011; Kitryte et al., 2015). Due to its high moisture content and fermentable sugar content, brewer’s spent grain deteriorates very easily becoming an environmental problem after a short time (El-Shafey et al., 2004). This is the reason why it is regarded as a problematic waste by the industry so any additional uses of BSG would be advantageous due to the increasing cost of their disposal (McCarthy et al., 2012). BSG is usually dried to over-come this problem. Dried BSG is considered as lignocellulosic material rich in hemicelluloses (39%), proteins (24%), cellulose (14%), lipids (6%), and lignin (4%) (Mussatto et al., 2006). BSG is mainly used as a feedstuff, fertilizer, source of energy and recently as a source for the production of alpha-amylase, activated carbon, ethanol, lactic acid and xylitol (Mussatto et al., 2006, Meneses et al., 2013). Due to its relatively low cost and nutritional value, together with pressure on the food industry to minimize the environmental impact, BSG has a great potential to be used as a valuable food additive (Santos et al., 2003; Laufenberg et al., 2003; Mussatto et al., 2006; Stojceska et al., 2008). This especially applies to the incorporation of BSG into different cereal based and bakery products (breads, cookies, snacks, cakes, waffles, etc.) which has been demonstrated by numerous investigations (Mussatto et al., 2006; Finley and Hanamoto, 1980; Kawka et al., 1999; Prentice & D’Appolonia, 1977; Kissell et al., 1979; Prentice et al., 1978; Stojceska and Ainsworth, 2008; Stojceska et al., 2008; Sudha et al., 2007; Ktenioudaki et al., 2012, 2013a).

Cookies are popular confectionery product made out of wheat flour. Since widely accepted and consumed, with relatively long shelf-life and ready-to-eat form, they represent a valuable supplementation vehicle for nutritional improvement (Arshad et al., 2007; Lorens et al., 1979). They are usually highly caloric, but low in protein and especially fibre content (Manley, 2011). BSG is particularly rich in protein and fibre content what makes it an ideal nutritional fortifier for cookies. However, any substitution of wheat flour with ingredients with higher fibre content results in the weakening of the gluten network. The main issue associated with the incorporation of BSG in food products is the effect on texture and flavour (Steinmacher et al., 2012; Ktenioudaki et al., 2013b). Considering cookies and biscuits, it has been reported that sensory attributes has been deteriorated following the addition of more than 15% of BSG (Kissell and Prentice, 1979).

BSG is usually prepared by grinding and sifting of dry BSG. Since drying can be considered as energy-consuming and expensive process, the primary objective of this study was to examine the effects of adding fresh (no-dried and no-milled) BSG on sensory and some nutritional properties of cookies. Since BSG was used in fresh form, the microbial stability of cookies was also examined.


Preparation of cookies

Blends of wheat flour containing 15, 25 and 50% of fresh, non-milled BSG, on a replacement basis, were prepared using the F-6-RVC agitator (Forberg International AS, Norway). Control cookie sample was prepared using wheat flour without BSG. Cookie doughs were prepared according to Petrović et al. (2015): flour (i.e. flour blend) 200.00 g, vegetable fat 42.00 g, sugar 70.00 g, sodium bicarbonate 0.6 g, ammonium hydrogen carbonate 0.4 g and NaCl 1.1 g. The amount of water was calculated in relation to the water content of the flour blends in order to obtain dough samples with 24% moisture content. Pre-pared cookie dough was baked for 10 min at 220 °C in a laboratory oven (Profil, Kragujevac, Serbia). Cookie sample with 15% BSG was marked as B15, with 25% BSG as B25 and with 50% BSG as B50, while control sample was prepared only with wheat flour.

Determination of protein and fibre content

Protein content of cookies was determined according to the Kjeldahl method described in the AOAC (2000). The factor n = 6.25 for cookies were used for conversion of nitrogen to crude protein (Arshad et al., 2007). The total dietary fibre content was determined using a combination of enzymatic and gravimetric methods (Sigma-Aldrich Inc., St. Louis, MO, USA) (AOAC, 1997). Milled and defatted samples were gelatinized with heat stable α-amylase and then enzymatically digested with protease and amyloglucosidase to remove protein and starch present in the sample. Ethanol was added to precipitate the soluble dietary fibre. The residue was then filtered and washed with ethanol and acetone. After drying, the residue was weighed. One duplicate was analysed for protein and the other was incubated at 525 °C to determine ash. Total dietary fibre is the weight of the residue less the weight of the protein and ash.

Microbiological analysis

Microbiological analyses were performed on fresh BSG used for cookie preparation and on cookie samples in duplicate. Twenty grams of samples were homogenized for 10 min at 200 rpm (Unimax 1010, Heidolph, Germany) in 180 mL 1 g/L buffered peptone water (Merck, Darmstadt) and then sequence of decimal dilution were prepared (up to 10-3). One millilitre of each dilution was placed in a sterile Petri plate and poured with appropriate media depending on the type of tested microorganism. Total aerobic mesophilic bacteria count was enumerated in Plate Count Agar (PCA) (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) and incubated at 30 °C for 72 h; total yeasts and moulds count was enumerated in Dichloran Rose Bengal Chloramphenicol agar (DRBC) (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) and incubated at 25 °C for 5 days; Escherichia coli was determined on Tryptone Bile Glucuronic Agar (TBX agar) (Merck, Darmstadt) after an incubation at 37 °C for 24-48 h; Clostridium spp. was determined on Tryptone Sulfite Cycloserine (TSC) Agar (Merck, Darmstadt) after an incubation under anaerobic conditions at 37 °C for 24-48 h; total Enterobacteriaceae count was enumerated in Violet Red Bile Glucose Agar (VRBGA) (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) at 37 °C for 24-48 h. After incubation, typical and atypical grown colonies have been identified by microscopic observation of cell morphology and also with biochemical tests. Results were expressed as a number of colony forming units per gram (cfu/g).

Cookie colour determination

Cookie’s upper surface colour was measured in triplicates, 24 h after baking. The CIELab colour coordinates (L* - light-ness, a* - redness to greenness and b* - yellowness to blueness) (CIE, 1976) were deter-mined using MINOLTA Chroma Meter CR-400 (Minolta Co., Ltd., Osaka, Japan) using D-65 lighting, a 2° standard observer angle and an 8-mm aperture in the measuring head. The Chroma Meter was calibrated using a Minolta calibration plate (No. 11333090; Y = 92.9, x = 0.3159; y = 0.3322).

Sensory analysis

Cookie samples were evaluated by a panel of 25 members, students and staff of the Faculty of Technology, University of Novi Sad, 24 h after baking. In order to evaluate cookie sensory characteristics (appearance, hardness, chewiness, odour, taste and overall acceptability) panellists used 5 - point hedonic scale (1 - dislike very much, 2 – dislike moderately, 3 - neither like nor dislike 4 – like moderately, 5 - like very much) (ISO 4121:2002). Cookie samples were served to panellists on white plastic plates labelled with three-digit codes from a random number table. Water and slices of bread were used to clean the mouth between samples.

Statistical analysis

Statistical analysis was carried out using STATISTICA 12.0 (StatSoft, Inc., Tulsa, OK, USA). All data were presented as mean value with their standard deviation indicated (mean ± SD). Variance analysis (ANOVA) was performed, with a confidence interval of 95% (p < 0.05). Means were compared by Duncan's multiple range test.

Results and Discussion

Protein and fibre content

Control sample had statistically significantly (p<0.05) lower protein and fibre content compared to samples with BSG (Table 1). Protein and total fibre content increased significantly with BSG percentage used for cookies preparation. Cookie sample with 50% of BSG had 9.69% protein and even 15.55% total fibre, which is 1.75 times as much as protein and 5 times as much as fibre compared to sample prepared only with wheat flour. These results confirm that BSG is a potential nutritious food supplement. While the control sample had an equal share of insoluble and soluble fibre, in the cookie samples with BSG the amount of insoluble fibre was significantly higher compared to the amount of soluble fibre. Kissell and Prentice (1979) showed that BSG addition at 20% doubled the crumb protein and lysine content of cookies and increased dietary fibre content by more than fivefold.

Microbiological analysis

The results of the microbial counts are reported in Table 2. The total number of aerobic mesophilic bacteria was the highest in fresh BSGs (4.0×105cfu/g). The composition of brewers’ spent grain makes it susceptible to microbial attack and chemical deterioration (Robertson et al., 2010). The total number of aerobic mesophilic bacteria increased with increasing amounts of BSG in the cookie samples, and it was highest in sample B50. Yeast and moulds, Escherichia coli and Clostridium spp. were not detected in fresh BSG or in cookie samples. In fresh BSG, Enterobacteriaceae were detected (40 cfu/g), while in all final products, cookie
samples, were not.

Cookie colour

Colour is one of the most important parameters by which consumers evaluate food (Pathare et al., 2013). The colour parameters, lightness (L* value), redness (a* value) and yellowness (b* value) of examined cookies are shown in Table 3. The addition of BSG significantly affected (P < 0.05) lightness (L* value) and redness (a* value) of samples. Addition of BSG in cookie formulation decreased L* values, i.e. the samples became darker, which is especially pronounced in the sample with 50% BSG. On the other hand, certain differences in yellowness (b* value) were not registered between control and samples B25 and B15. The addition of BSG significantly affected cookie yellowness (b* value) only at the amount of 50%. Ktenioudaki et al., (2013), also concluded that the colour of the crispy slices became visually darker as the level of BSG increased.

Table 1. Protein and fibre composition (%) of cookie samples



Total fibre

Insoluble fibre

Soluble fibre





















Results are given as mean ± standard deviation (n = 3); Means with different letters in superscript (a-d) in columns are significantly different (p< 0.05)

Table 2. Microbiological profile (cfu/g) of cookies


Total aerobic mesophilic bacteria

Total yeasts and moulds

Escherichia coli

Clostridium spp.


Total aerobic mesophilic sporulated bacteria




































n.d.= not detected

Table 3.CIE L*, a*, b* values of cookie color





















Results are given as mean ± standard deviation (n = 3); Means with different letters in superscript (a-d) in columns are significantly different (p < 0.05)

Sensory analysis

The panellists have given higher scores for all evaluated attributes to the control cookie sample (Figure 1.). Kim et al., (2001) also reported that the overall sensory score decreased when biscuits contained more than 15% BSG. Kissell and Prentice (1979) found that BSG addition was limited to 15% before an unacceptable flavour developed in cookies. Prentice and D’Appolonia (1977) reported that breads with 5 and 10% BSG had good sensory properties and were accepted by consumers. In the cookie samples B15, B25 and B50, parts of BSG and cracks were visible on the cookie surface. Addition of BSG generally influenced the formation of a darker co-okies colour as a result of higher protein content in BSG which caused intensive Maillard reactions (Rufián-Henares et al., 2009). The negative impact BSG addition had on the hardness and chewiness. BSG has high amount of proteins and fibre which absorb water causing cookie hardening. Because they were not milled, addition of BSG in cookies leads to the ap-pearance of large particles in the mouth. The samples with highest BSG level (B50) had the higher amount of small, hard particles that lag between teeth during chewing. This sample had the lowest scores for chewiness. For odour, taste and overall acceptability the highest score was given to sample B25 and the lowest score to sample B50.

Figure 1. Sensory characteristics of control cookie and cookies with BSG. The means followed by different letters are indicated as significantly different (p < 0.05)


The results confirm that BSG is a potential nutritious food supplement. Cookie sample with 50% of BSG had 1.75 times as much as protein and 5 times as much as fibre compared to sample prepared only with wheat flour. On the other hand, although fresh BSG possessed Enterobacteriaceae, they were not detected in cookie samples, as well as E. coli, Clostridium spp., yeasts and moulds. Addition of BSG in cookies formulation decreased L* and increased a* values of cookie colour. The results of sensory analysis showed that cookie samples were well evaluated for appearance by panellists. Addition of BSG had nega-tive impact on the hardness and chewiness of cookies. The highest values for overall acceptability, odour and taste had sample B25. It can be concluded that BSG used fresh, no-milled and without thermal treatment, immediately after beer processing, do not impair microbiological stability and sensory characteristics of co-okies, while increase its nutritional value.

The maximum amount of fresh BSG that would be included in cookie preparation should not exceed 25%, since larger amount caused significantly lower scores for cookies sensory characteristics.


The authors highly appreciate financial support of the Provincial Secretariat for High Education and Scientific Research of the Government of Autonomous Province of Vojvodina, Republic of Serbia, project 114-451-2085/2016: Valorization of by-products of the food industry through the development of nutritionally enriched co-okies and cracker.

Download full article PDF



  1. AOAC (2000). Official Methods of Analysis of AOAC International, 17th Ed, Gaithersburg, MD, USA.
  2. AOAC (1997). Official methods Methods of analysis Analysis of AOAC International, 16th Washington, DC., Official Method 985.29.
  3. Arshad, M.U., Anjum, F.M., Zahoor, T. (2007). Nutritional assessment of cookies supplemented with defatted wheat germ. Food Chemistry, 102, 123-128.
  4. International Commission on Illumination(1976). Official recommendations on uniform colour space, colour difference equations and metric colour terms. In Colorimetry, 2nd Ed. 9–12. Publication CIENo.15.2. Commission International de l'Eclairage, Paris, France.
  5. ISO 4121:2002 (2002). Sensory analysis - Methodology - Evaluation of food product by methods of using scales, International Organization for Standardization.
  6. El‐Shafey, E.I., Gameiro, M.L.F., Correia, P.F.M., De Carvalho, J.M.R. (2004). Dewatering of brewer's spent grain using a membrane filter press: a pilot plant study.Separation Science and Technology39 (14), 3237-3261.
  7. Finley, J.W., Hanamoto, M.M. (1980). Milling and baking properties of dried brewer's spent grains.Cereal Chemistry, 57, 166–168
  8. Kawka, A., Gorecka, D., Gąsiorowski, H. (1999). The effects of commercial barley flakes on dough characteristics and bread compo-sition.Electronic Journal of Polish Agricultural Universities2 (2), 1-8.
  9. Kissell, L.T., Prentice, N. (1979). Protein and fibre enrichment of cookie flour with brewer's spent grain.Cereal Chemistry56 (4), 261-266.
  10. Kim, H.Y.L., Yeom, H.W., Lim, H.S., & Lim, S.T. (2001). Replacement of shortening in yellow layer cakes by corn dextrins. Cereal Chemistry, 78 (3), 267-271.
  11. Kitrytė, V., Šaduikis, A., Venskutonis, P.R. (2015). Assessment of antioxidant capacity of brewer’s spent grain and its supercritical carbon dioxide extract as sources of valuable dietary ingredients. Journal of Food Engineering, 167, 18-24.
  12. Ktenioudaki, A., Chaurin, V., Reis, S.F., Gallagher, E. (2012). Brewer’s spent grain as a functional ingredient for breadsticks.Interna-tional Journal of Food Science & Techno-logy47 (8), 1765-1771.
  13. Ktenioudaki, A., O’Shea, N., Gallagher, E. (2013a). Rheological properties of wheat dough supplemented with functional by-products of food processing: Brewer’s spent grain and apple pomace. Journal of Food Engineering116 (2), 362-368.
  14. Ktenioudaki, A., Crofton, E., Scannell, A.G., Hannon, J.A., Kilcawley, K.N., Gallagher, E. (2013b). Sensory properties and aromatic composition of baked snacks containing brewer's spent grain. Journal of Cereal Science57 (3), 384-390.
  15. Laufenberg, G., Kunz, B., Nystroem, M. (2003). Transformation of vegetable waste into value added products: (A) the upgrading concept;(B) practical implementations.Bioresource Technology87 (2), 167-198.
  16. Lorens, K., Dilsaver, W., Wolt, M. (1979). Faba bean flour and protein concentrate in baked goods and in pasta products. Bakers Digest, 53, 39–42.
  17. Manley, D. (Ed.). (2011). Manley’s Technology of Biscuits, Crackers and Cookies. Woodhead Publishing Limited, Cambridge, England.
  18. McCarthy, A.L., O’Callaghan, Y.C., Connolly, A., Piggott, C.O., FitzGerald, R.J., O’Brien, N.M. (2012). Phenolic extracts of brewers’ spent grain (BSG) as functional ingredients–Assessment of their DNA protective effect against oxidant-induced DNA single strand breaks in U937 cells. Food Chemistry134 (2), 641-646.
  19. Meneses, N.G., Martins, S., Teixeira, J.A., Mussatto, S.I. (2013). Influence of extraction solvents on the recovery of antioxidant phenolic compounds from brewer’s spent grains. Separation and Purification Technology108, 152-158.
  20. Mussatto, S.I., Dragone, G., Roberto, I.C. (2006). Brewers' spent grain: generation, characteristics and potential applications. Journal of Cereal Science43 (1), 1-14.
  21. Pathare, P.B., Opara, U.L., Al-Said, F.A.J. (2013). Colour measurement and analysis in fresh and processed foods: a review. Food and Bioprocess Technology, 6 (1), 36-60.
  22. Petrović, J., Fišteš, A., Rakić, D., Pajin, B., Lončarević, I., Šubarić, D. (2015). Effect of defatted wheat germ content and its particle size on the rheological and textural properties of the cookie dough.Journal of Texture Studies46 (5), 374-384.
  23. Prentice, N., D'Appolonia, B.L. (1977). High-fiber bread containing brewer's spent grain.Ce-real Chemistry, 54, 1084–1095.
  24. Prentice, N., Kissell, L.T., Lindsay, R.C., Yamazaki, W.T. (1978). High-fiber cookies containing brewers' spent grain. Cereal Chemistry, 22, 470 – 465.
  25. Robertson, J.A., I’Anson, K.J., Brocklehurst, T.F., Faulds, C.B., & Waldron, K.W. (2010). Effect of storage conditions on the microbial ecology and biochemical stability of cell wall components in Brewers’ spent grain. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 58 (12), 7266-7272.
  26. Rodriguez, R., Jimenez, A., Fernández-Bo-laños, J., Guillén, R., Heredia, A. (2006). Die-tary fiber from vegetable products as source of functional ingredients. Trends in Food Science & Technology17 (1), 3-15.
  27. Rufián-Henares, J.A., Delgado-Andrade, C., Morales, F.J. (2009). Assessing the Maillard reaction development during the toasting pro-cess of common flours employed by the cereal products industry. Food Chemistry, 114 (1), 93-99.
  28. Santos, M., Jiménez, J.J., Bartolomé, B., Gómez-Cordovés, C., Del Nozal, M.J. (2003). Variability of brewer’s spent grain within a brewery.Food Chemistry80 (1), 17-21.
  29. Steinmacher, N.C., Honna, F.A., Gasparetto, A.V., Anibal, D., Grossmann, M.V. (2012). Bio-conversion of brewer’s spent grains by reactive extrusion and their application in bread-making.LWT-Food Science and Technology46 (2), 542-547.
  30. Stojceska, V. (2011). Dietary fibre from bre-wer’s spent grain as a functional ingredient in bread making technology. In Flour and Breads and their Fortification in Health and Disease Prevention, Eds. Preedy R. R. Watson V. Patel, Academic Press, Cambridge, Massachu-setts, pp. 171-179.
  31. Stojceska, V., Ainsworth, P. (2008). The effect of different enzymes on the quality of high-fibre enriched brewer’s spent grain breads.Food Chemistry110 (4), 865-872.
  32. Stojceska, V., Ainsworth, P., Plunkett, A., İbanogˇlu, S. (2008). The recycling of brewer's processing by-product into ready-to-eat snacks using extrusion technology.Journal of Cereal Science47 (3), 469-479.
  33. Sudha, M.L., Vetrimani, R., Leelavathi, K. (2007). Influence of fiber from different cereals on the rheological characteristics of wheat flour dough and on biscuit quality. Food Chemistry100 (4), 1365-1370.